Book Review: The Midnight Mayor (Matthew Swift Book 2) by Kate Griffin

swift2

Warning: this review contains spoilers.

My review of the first book in the series can be found here.

Our favourite resurrected sorcerer Matthew Swift isn’t having such a swell time lately. Not only has he entered a symbiotic relationship with every single blue electric angel of London, but somebody attacked him when he picked up a phone. Again! It appears that his late seer friend was right when he said: “You’re, like, gonna die. It’s after when it gets complicated”.

As he chases his attacker while wearing someone else’s shoes for a very good reason, as we learn later, Matthew witnesses a murder of the Mayor of London. No, not the Mayor of London everyone knows. The other Mayor. The Midnight Mayor. And that’s when things get REALLY complicated. Firsly, Matthew Swift doesn’t even believe in the Midnight Mayor. Secondly, the Aldermen show up to interrupt his recovery. The Aldermen only come out at night whenever it is necessary to ensure London’s safety. They serve the Midnight Mayor. And naturally, they suspect Matthew Swift as the murderer. However, as Swift conducts his own investigation, he learns that the Mayor’s death is the least of the evils London is facing. The ravens in the Tower of London are dead. The London Stone is gone. The London Wall is defaced. And it is up to Matthew Swift to protect London from the invoked curse. A curse of five words that seem to be all over London. “Give Me Back My Hat“.

Finding the villain in question is the easy part – Death of the Cities makes Matthew Swift’s bloods (both red and blue) run cold. The tricky part is to figure out who brought Him into London. Whose hat was stolen? And what do Matthew Swift’s borrowed shoes have to do with anything?

Poor Matthew Swift doesn’t even get the option to leave it all to the Aldermen or the “mystic forces”.

Why is that?

Because he is the new Midnight Mayor. And no-one’s happy.

I was very pleased to learn that “The Midnight Mayor” doesn’t suffer from a second-book curse (unlike London). In fact, I enjoyed it even more than “A Madness of Angels”. Whether it was because I got to know the world built by Kate Griffin in the first book and was overjoyed to learn even more about it in “The Midnight Mayor”, or because this installment’s descriptions were worded better and different sides of Swift’s character were shown, this book felt like a rich, decadent chocolate cake one loves so much. However, while the first book was certainly rich in the “chocolate” elements (descriptions and world-building), in “The Midnight Mayor” the author adds a dash of “ginger” – action scenes are more gritty and much more disturbing, and a pinch of “red velvet” – emotions. While I considered the main character of “A Madness of Angels” to be London, the sequel is more Matthew Swift-centric. We are shown that the sorcerer and the angels are as “human” as us. This is demonstrated in his fear of The Aldermen and Death of Cities. To be fair, we all would be afraid of a guy who bleeds paper, can’t be killed and quite literally feasts on “the fall of walls, on the shattering of roofs, on the breaking of the street, the bursting of the pipies, the snapping of the wires, the running of the people”. From the way the book ends, it is apparent that he’s going to be the Moriarty to Matthew’s Holmes. And don’t worry – not once did Swift lose his determination to sass everybody!

Penny and Oda are only two of the awesome supporting characters of the series. I’ve mentioned that Griffin is very good at writing them in my review of “A Madness of Angels”, and I stand by what I said. Not only does the supporting cast have great backstories (to reveal them would be very spoilery at this point), but they are incredibly diverse. We have two black ladies – a religious assassin who greets Swift with a “One day I’ll kill you” every time she sees him, and a woman who holds the future of the city in her hand (metaphorically speaking). We have a badass leader of the Whites, a “rag-tag formation of egoists, magicians, artists and all-purpose mystic dabblers, donating to a common union”, a lady whom we’ve met in the first book and whom I was really happy to see again. And last, but not least, we have an amazing, multi-dimensional (in every sense) protagonist who is canonically asexual. The lack of romance in this book works really well.

However, the focus character development does not mean that the worldbuiling in “The Midnight Mayor” is put on hold. Griffin, quite masterfully, interwines the elements of London’s urban magic with Matthew’s adventures and character growth. Take The Midnight Mayor and the Aldermen, for instance. Before he became one, Swift didn’t even believe that The Midnight Mayor existed. Now he’s working with the people he loathes which are both a big part of the magical London and a plot device that drives Swift to act in certain ways. He describes them as “protectors of the stones, the memory and the riches and the buildings of the city, but not the people”. This is one of the conflicts of the story – Matthew Swift, both as a Mayor and a person, protects the people first, as we see by the end of the book with Penny, as well as with Oda who has been his frenemy from Book 1. Another conflict emerges from the protagonist’s ongoing “Swift vs angels” internal battle and the idea of who The Midnight Mayor is supposed to be. The concept comes from an understanding that “London is an antheap” and “we are insignificant” and dependent on the “bricks and stones of London“. The Aldermen are trained to think that way, and The Midnight Mayor always comes from the Aldermen for that very reason. Enter Matthew Swift, a sorcerer and the angels who are obsessed with life and consider it the best magic of all. Swift and Angels are megalomaniacs in that way. “Life is magic” doesn’t bode well with the concept, the idea of The Midnight Mayor, protector of the City. This conflict causes a lot of tension between Swift and Aldermen, culminating in them reluctantly working together towards a common goal. But as you can probably guess, it does not end well.

The writing, like I mentioned earlier, is as decadent, and quotable as the first book (see “Favourite quotes” for a sneak peek at the gems). Griffin, while being a very good character and plot writer, is something else entirely when it comes to atmospheric writing. Through the eyes of Swift and the Angels, we see the London we haven’t seen before. You may have thought you’ve gotten enough of it in the rich first installment, but the sequel just makes you crave more and more. But even with all the magic, you never forget that the setting is England. Seriously – this book is incredibly English. A few examples include a murder by a tea kettle after offering the victim a cuppa, Swift almost drowning in a cauldron of three-thousand-year-old tea, and not asking strangers their business when waiting for the bus. Matthew Swift even knows that when London Underground isn’t telling you when the next train is due, you can usually assume it’s bad news.

Kate Griffin knows the significance of every detail and, while it does sometime result in wordy, several pages long descriptions, it really gives you an insight into the magical London. My favourite aspect has to be the dragon. Well – what Swift sees as a dragon. Domine digire nos. The dragon is the protector of London, whom we meet in the first book. In “The Midnight Mayor”, we learn that “dragon” is a representation of London as a whole, a way for “mortals to understand something too big for the brain“. Dragon is just the form it takes, and when Swift meets it, he understands that while life may be magic, the city of London is much bigger than any mortal, even him. The Midnight Mayor doesn’t keep a dragon – the dragon keeps him. Although how he gets away with calling the dragon “Fido” is beyond me.

As I said above, the sequel to “A Madness of Angels” contains all the great things from the first installment, but it doesn’t end there. It is delicious. However, too much of a good thing is not always the best thing involved. My advice is to not binge on the Matthew Swift series over the weekend – not only is that practically impossible since the books are massive, but like with any rich chocolate gateau, they are best enjoyed in moderation. Which is why I’m taking a short break from reading them for now. I could probably write several more paragraphs about relationships in this book, but you’re probably bored by now! So I’ll conclude this review by rating “The Midnight Mayor” 8.5/10. 

Favourite quotes

“You are nothing more than a 01010101001 in a computer! Jesus Christ, if that isnt the definition of so dead you could drop it down a pyramid for a party then I don’t know what is!”

“Am I really dead?”

“You got shot and turned into a puddle of paint.”

“That’s not normal corpselike behaviour.”

“If you weren’t such a pustulent testicle with it, I’d almost feel sorry for electrocuting you”. 

“The world, this living world is so full of incident, strangeness, experience, event, happening so busy and so fast, that it’s a wonder you mortals don’t go mad”.

Dreamcast

Matthew Swift – Benedict Cumberbatch

Dudley Sinclair – Geoffrey Rush

Oda – Freema Agyeman

Penny Ngwenya – Noma Dumezweni 

Vera – Helen McCrory

Anissina – Aubrey Plaza

Mr Earle – Gary Oldman

Mr Pinner – Michael Gambon

Book Review: A Madness of Angels (Matthew Swift Book 1) by Kate Griffin

swift1

(Guys, I opened an Etsy charity shop! Check it out and help stop human trafficking!)

Warning: this review contains spoilers

What if every surface of the London as you know it is impregnated with magic? What if the urban legends about the Bag Lady, the Litterbugs with a purpose, direction and intent, and the Seven Sisters are not legends at all? And what if you’re a powerful sorcerer, whose power comes from the magic of urban life such as tube stations and graffiti, and who just happens to be dead?

Except you are, apparently, not.

Matthew Swift wakes up one morning in his bedroom in London. Nothing wrong with that picture, right? Except Matthew Swift has been murdered two years ago. And as far as he is concerned, Matthew Swift has always been the only thing inside his body. Until now. Thousands, if not millions of beings are the “we” now. We are me and I am us. Who are they?

The answer is, that they are angels. Except they are as far removed from Gabriel, Michael and other Biblical entities as can be. They are the thoughts we leave behind after we hang up the phone. They are the feelings we forget, the voices lost in interference, the surplus of magic lost across the wires and cables across the world. They are the product of humanity that began as a rogue piece of static and over the years, fed on all the life being thrown at them – telephone conversations, radio broadcasts, e-mails – that unique magic made them take a life of its own as blue electric angels. And now, all those angels are trapped in Matthew Swift’s body.

Swift has been murdered by an unknown horror known as The Shadow, which just happens to have a face of his old mentor Robert Bakker, a broken man who’s been looking for a way to get to the angels for a very long time. When Swift is resurrected, there is only one thing on his mind – revenge. Fortunately (or unfortunately), there are certain concerned citizens who want Bakker dead and his organisation, The Tower, destroyed. To do so, this group of warlocks, wizards, magicians, weremen and other magical beings recruits Swift and tasks him with killing Bakker. The pursuit of his revenge involves pranking large corporations, fighting shadows, recruiting The Beggar King and the Whites, an underground clan, and entering into a very reluctant alliance with a religious order that hates the angels. What exactly happened the night Matthew Swift died? Who or what exactly is The Shadow? And how is Matthew Swift alive?

Urban fantasy can make a traveller squeal when describing the magic of places they have been to. I am certain that London is one of my favourite places on Earth, which is a big reason why I loved Gaiman’s “Neverwhere”. “A Madness of Angels” treats London the same way – except in the Matthew Swift ‘verse, the city is literally the source of all kinds of magic. And there are so many ways magic can be drawn from it. The deepest, darkest secrets of London are the magic that is pulsing all over the place. The abandoned tube stations, the graffiti that can tell you the way to an entrace to a secret society and of course, the surplus of electric impulses infused with essence of humans that makes an angel are only a few of many aspects of the book that would make any urban fantasy lover’s heart swell. Really, the descriptions of magic in different cities, some of which I’ve been to, were one of my favourite bits of the novel – “In Madrid, the shadows are waiting at every corner to whisper their histories in your ear when you walk at night. In Beijing the sense of it was a prickling heat on the skin, like the wind had been broken down into a thousand pieces, and each part carried some warmth from another place, and brushed against your skin, like a furry cat calling for your attention”. Mrs Griffin, you’re making me nostalgic!

The main character, Matthew Swift, died while on the phone and as a result, the angels entered into a symbiotic relationship with him. They are reluctant to call it “possession” because it’s “more complicated than that”. Since this is the first time angels are experiencing life as a non-celestial, corporeal entity, they are overwhelmed, confused and fascinated. For them, life is magic in a “more mundane sense of the word; the act of living being magic all of its own”. Swift and the angels are written as one and the same, but there are constant switches between first person singular and first person plural narrator – at first, it is unclear as to why this is done, but if a reader is immersed and invested, it makes for an interesting literary device. Obviously, as Swift approaches the end of his pursuit, an internal conflict begins to form. It wasn’t prominent before because both Swift and the angels were too overwhelmed by the sudden issue of… well, being alive, but the reader begins to see a type of cognitive dissonance between the narrators. The sassy English nurse (not unlike Claire Beuchamp of Outlander) begins to bring that out in him – “Mr Swift, did you bother to consider some of the medical implications of being injured by a creature of pure darkness before you rashly engaged it in mortal combat? I doubt it. Young people never do.”  This is where the lines established by the narrators between themselves arguably begin to blur and he begins to realise that “life is magic and magic is not life”. This phrase can be suggested to be the primary lesson/theme/idea of the novel, or perhaps even the entire series (I’ll start reading the next book ASAP by the way), and is the source of many conflicts in the novel – the internal conflict of Swift and the angels, as well as his conflict with Bakker and some others.

Swift’s backstory is revealed in an interlude while he is interrogated by a religious order. The entire novel is split into three parts and two interludes, no chapters. Admittedly, that does make it harder to follow. And to be fair, this is not the book that can be just “consumed” or read while you’re doing something else. This novel requires concentration and full immersion into the magical London. That wasn’t an issue for me, but I can see how it would be for some people. Griffin’s writing did sometimes feel like an attempt at “purple prose” – and for me, it worked (and the book is very quotable as a result), but only when she was elaborating on the atmosphere and the setting. Some pages were just one lengthy paragraph, which was a bit of a turn-off. However, with the exception of the very beginning and just before the ending, it wasn’t a problem. Nevertheless, if I were the author, I wouldn’t have started this book with a lengthy description and an info-dump – it can be rather off-putting. None of the faults with the writing and/or the story prevent me, however, from giving “A Madness of Angels” a rating of 8/10. 

Favourite character

It can honestly be said that London is the central character of the novel. This sort of thing has been done with “Sherlock”, but unlike “Matthew Swift”, the story in the TV series revolves primarily around characters. In this book, however, the capital of the United Kingdom steals the glory – Kate Griffin (also known as Catherine Webb) is clearly a London aficionado like myself and is not afraid to show it. The plot is not too complex – revenge stories are rather common, as are the tropes of religious fanatics and several rivals banding together to overthrow a villain – and the side characters have more potential than explored in this installment of the series, so it is fair to say that the city (including The City) of London is both a setting and a player in the novel. This book does have many traces of typical “Englishness”, including the emotionless, deadpan reactions and pure sass in the dialogue. I do love that kind of thing!

Favourite quotes

To send your soul across the infinite void faster than the blink of the mind dreaming in the moonlight, please press hash now”.

“Some ideas are more than just random moments of good inspiration. Some ideas become real whether you mean them or not”.

“Men in bandages feel so righteous it’s almost unbearable. Not having period pains every month gives them a whole superiority complex, but when they’re in bandages they just want to be loved”.

Dreamcast

Matthew Swift – Benedict Cumberbatch. And I’m not being serendipitous because of Neverwhere – he literally has the perfect eyes for the part. And honestly – this cover really reminds me of Khan!

Robert Bakker – Derek Jacobi

Sinclair – Geoffrey Rush

Oda – Freema Agyeman

Dana – Lucy Fry

Recommendations

The Matthew Swift series are for you if you enjoyed:

“Neverwhere” by Neil Gaiman

“Rivers of London” by Ben Aaronovitch

“Supernatural”, “Doctor Who” and “Sherlock” – also known as “Superwholock”